Keep publishing when you can't see the return

Darrell Gardiner·Guide

Time magazine's CTO read Tyler Denk's founder emails for six months before backing a move to Beehiiv. Most of your buyers read without replying too.

Keep publishing when you can't see the return

It's 8pm and you're writing an email to your list. Nobody replied to the last three, the open rate is fine, and there's a client problem waiting that feels far more urgent than this. Send it anyway, because the person who ends up buying from you is probably reading and saying nothing.

Source: Tyler Denk, CEO and co-founder of Beehiiv, posted about how Time magazine became a customer. I talked through it in this video. The migration figures are from Tyler's post and Beehiiv's case study notes as I read them. The Beehiiv revenue figure is from a quick check of my own and is unverified. The maths on what one email is worth, and the advice at the end, are mine.

A reader who never replied

Tyler writes founder emails about what's happening inside Beehiiv. One of the people on his list was Burhan Hamid, who was Time's CTO at the time. Burhan read those emails for about six months, never replied, and then pushed internally for Time to move its newsletters over.

The move was a big one. Tyler's numbers put it at 2 million subscribers across 13 newsletters, migrated with zero downtime and a white-glove onboarding. From a quick check, Beehiiv sits at around $30 million in annual recurring revenue with a goal of $50 million by the end of the year, though I haven't verified that figure. I'd guess Time is one of the largest customers they have.

Tyler didn't email Burhan personally, and nobody ran an outbound campaign at Time. Once a list passes a few thousand people you stop knowing who's on it, and Burhan may well have signed up from a personal address. From Tyler's side, those six months probably looked like any other six months of sending.

What one email was worth

I love a dashboard, and this is one thing a dashboard won't show you. Say Tyler sent one email a week across those six months. That's roughly twenty-five emails, and any of them could have been the one that tipped Burhan from reader to advocate. Tyler doesn't know which, and I doubt Burhan could tell you either.

Split a multi-year enterprise contract across twenty-five emails and each one carried a serious amount of revenue on the night it was written. The analytics for every one of them would have shown opens, a few clicks and no replies from anyone at Time.

This has tripped me up for years. You write a reel, a LinkedIn post or an email, nothing visible comes back, and something louder shows up in the business. The work that moves fastest gets the hour, and the work that compounds gets pushed to next week and then the week after.

Silent readers are still forming a view

The people who become your biggest customers often aren't the ones commenting. They open the email, watch the reel, and go back to running whatever they run. Each piece adds a little to their picture of who you are and how you operate.

Then a contract ends on their side, or a tool stops working for them, and they go with the person they already have a view of. If you stopped publishing three months earlier, their picture of you is three months old. Someone else has been in their inbox since.

Consistency carries its own message here. Seeing a founder show up every week tells a buyer something about how that founder runs the rest of the business, separate from what any single email says.

The product has to hold up its end

Publishing opened the door at Time and the product closed the deal. Two million subscribers moved without downtime, with a team walking them through it. If that migration had gone badly, six months of good emails would have bought Tyler a short and awkward sales call.

So I wouldn't read this story as "post more and the deals arrive." I'd read it as two jobs that depend on each other. The emails got Beehiiv a champion inside Time, and the product gave that champion something he could stand behind in a room full of his own colleagues.

Three things to do this week

  • Pick the piece you'd normally skip because you can't tell if it's worth the time. Write it, publish it, and don't look at the numbers for a month.
  • Say no to one "quick" request and put that hour into content you can't measure yet.
  • Publish something specific from inside the business, the kind of detail that usually stays in a team chat and gets forgotten.

I can't promise a Time magazine is reading your emails. What I can say is that you won't know who's on the other end until one of them acts, and they can only act on what you've sent.

Next post

Can you say it in one sentence?

October 6, 2026

Ready to Fire up Your Flow?

Create Your Clipflow Account Today

Built for content operations, business teams at scale and new entrants looking to start right.

14 Day Free Trial (No Credit Card)