| Best for | Content teams that want review, planning and publishing in one place | Agencies collecting sign-off on video, PDFs and images from outside clients | Larger teams that need staged approval workflows and editing-app plugins | Small teams that only need fast video review at the lowest per-seat price | Editors who already keep their files in Dropbox and cut in Premiere, Final Cut or Resolve | Teams with a large media library that need asset management as well as review | Baseline, not ranked |
| Cost for 6 people | $174/mo | $199/mo | $199/mo | $120/mo | AU$92.40/mo (AUD) | No fixed total: $0 to $120 per user by seat type | $150/mo |
| Frame-accurate comments | Yes, timestamped comments and drawing on the frame | Yes, comments on specific frames | Yes, comments on specific frames or a time range | Yes, feedback pinned to the exact frame | Yes, frame-accurate edit notes | Yes, time-based comments and on-screen annotations | Yes, notes pinned to the exact frame |
| Client review without a login | Yes, share links with no login or seat | Yes, reviewers approve with an email address only | Yes, reviewers need no paid license | Yes, reviewers don't need an account | Not stated on Dropbox's page | Yes, per Iconik, external reviewers need no account | Yes, reviewers view and comment without an account |
| Version comparison | Yes, compare file versions in the project | Yes, side by side from Starter; overlay compare on Business | Yes, pixel-level compare, including on the free plan | Yes, compare any two versions side by side | Versions supported; comparison not detailed | Yes, version control and comparison | Yes, compare two versions side by side |
| Approval status | Yes, Approved and Changes required statuses that trigger automations | Yes, approve on every plan; approve with changes and reject on Business | Yes, approvals tracked through staged workflows | Yes, approval workflows with an audit trail | Final approval stated; status labels not detailed | Yes, approval status set on the asset | Review and approval flow, status labels not detailed on its site |
| Planning and publishing | Yes, ideas, tasks and a post calendar across channels | Review stages and due dates only; no post calendar or publishing | Review stages only; no post calendar or publishing | No, review only | No, review only | No, media asset management and review | No, review only |
| Editing-app plugins | None listed | Premiere Pro and After Effects | Premiere Pro, Final Cut Pro and DaVinci Resolve | Premiere Pro and Final Cut Pro | Premiere Pro, Final Cut Pro and DaVinci Resolve | Premiere Pro panel | Premiere Pro listed; Final Cut Pro and DaVinci Resolve not confirmed |
| Paid plans | $29/user, or $424/mo for unlimited users | Starter $199/mo, Business $329/mo, Enterprise custom (flat, 10 seats each) | Standard $199/mo, Pro $329/mo (both billed annually), Enterprise custom | Light $9.95/mo (individuals), Team $19.95/user, Enterprise custom | Bundled in Dropbox Plus, Standard and Advanced; AU$15.40 per user a month on Dropbox's Australian page, no US price shown | Starter (usage-based), Professional and Enterprise custom | Pro $15/member, Team $25/member, Enterprise custom |
| Free plan | No (14-day trial, no credit card) | Yes, 1 active project, 5 new files a month, 2GB | Yes, 2 users, 2GB, 60 days of review history | No (free trial, no credit card) | Limited version on Dropbox Basic | No (free trial; Collaborator seats are $0) | Yes, 2 seats, 2GB and 2 projects |
| G2 rating | Not listed yet | 4.6/5 (240+ reviews) | 4.5/5 (900+ reviews) | 4.7/5 (50+ reviews) | No separate Replay listing found | No G2 rating found | 4.5/5 (170+ reviews) |